Manager Enablement

Healthcare's performance review problem starts with overloaded managers

Healthcare leaders see less value in performance reviews than other industries do. See why overloaded managers may be the cause, and how to lighten the load.

Aimie Lim

7 min read

Healthcare's performance review problem starts with overloaded managers

Key takeaways

  • The value gap: Only 52% of healthcare business leaders say formal reviews help execute strategic priorities, compared with 77% in other industries. Healthcare leaders were also less likely to say formal reviews help managers prioritize effectively (55% vs. 81%) or help their organization make faster decisions (45% vs. 70%).

  • Manager overload is a likely contributor. Some hospital managers oversee roughly 100 to 300 employees, and 93% of nurse leaders handled administrative work in the previous week, according to the American Organization for Nursing Leadership (AONL).

  • Why reviews become paperwork: late, and focus on completing the cycle instead of coaching.

  • The fix: Take work off managers instead of adding process. Capture goals and feedback all year, draft evaluations from that record, fit the review to the team, and keep the documentation hospitals need.

Some nurse managers have 100 people reporting to them, others have 150, and at one health system we spoke with, some were responsible for up to 300 employees.

Each of them is still expected to write a meaningful annual review for every person on their team.

That workload may help explain why healthcare leaders see less payoff from reviews than leaders elsewhere. In Betterworks research, only 52% of healthcare business leaders said formal reviews help their organization execute strategic priorities, compared with 77% in other industries.

We can't prove what's behind that 25-point gap, but what hospital leaders have told us, along with independent data on nurse leader workload, points to one likely contributor: the managers responsible for reviews are stretched too thin to do them well. And a process nobody has time to do well can do little for strategy, prioritization, or decision speed.


The value gap shows up in execution, prioritization, and speed

Betterworks asked business leaders whether formal performance reviews help their organizations get work done. Healthcare leaders were far less convinced than leaders in other industries.

Healthcare versus other-industry leaders who say reviews help execute strategic priorities: 52% versus 77%; prioritize effectively: 55% versus 81%; and make faster decisions: 45% versus 70%. Source: Betterworks proprietary performance management surveys, October 2026. Healthcare business leaders, n=42; US and UK respondents. Cross-industry differences were statistically significant.

That's a gap of 25 to 26 points on each question, and it comes as hospital costs are climbing faster than prices. Total hospital expenses rose 7.5% in 2025, more than twice the 3.3% growth in hospital prices, according to the American Hospital Association, and about 60% of hospital expenses are workforce-related.

With that much spending tied to people, a review process that leaders don't believe in is hard to justify.

This reflects what leaders believe reviews accomplish, and it says nothing direct about how well any individual review is written. The belief still counts, though. A leader who doesn't expect reviews to help with prioritizing or decisions isn't likely to use them for either.


A review process designed for 10 direct reports doesn't scale to 100

Most performance processes assume a manager who knows each person well enough to write about them. A corporate manager with 10 direct reports can do that. A nurse manager with 100 can't, at least not in a compressed window.

In our conversations with hospital HR and talent leaders, the spans of control have been hard to ignore:

  • Roughly 100 direct reports for some nurse leaders at one health system

  • Approximately 150 employees per leader at another

  • Up to 300 employees for some managers at a third

At that scale, the annual cycle becomes a volume problem. At one of those systems, evaluations were concentrated between October and December, the same stretch as holidays, staffing pressure, and higher patient demand. Leaders there wanted to spread conversations across the year for exactly that reason.

[Pull quote placeholder: approved customer quote on review volume, pending Spartanburg sign-off]

Writing the review is only part of the work. Managers also have to gather information, recall what each person did and when, document feedback, and follow up. For a manager with 100 people, that means holding a year of individual detail in their head and turning it into 100 evaluations on top of everything else they're responsible for.


Administrative work is already crowding out leadership

The review burden lands on managers who are carrying plenty already. The American Organization for Nursing Leadership (AONL) found in its 2025 Nursing Leadership Insight Study that 93% of nurse leaders handled administrative work in the previous week. One in three (33%) named it among their most frustrating responsibilities.

At the same time, the people part of the job keeps growing:

  • 69% of nurse leaders in the same study reported spending time on mentoring, guiding, and performance reviews, up from 66% in 2023

  • 89% of respondents in Betterworks' healthcare manager-effectiveness survey said employee development had become more important

  • 86% said the same about coaching

Those respondents also wanted a different balance: 58% wanted managers spending less time on administrative reporting. And 48% wanted them spending more time coaching and developing employees.

Expectations for coaching and development are rising, and administrative work is still nearly universal. A formal review cycle lands on top of both.

How much of your managers’ year goes to the review cycle? We’ll help you map where the time goes.

Talk to an Expert


When managers are stretched this thin, reviews turn into paperwork

Overloaded managers don't skip reviews. They finish them the only way they can. That tends to look like this:

  • Reviews get written from memory. Without a running record of goals, feedback, and accomplishments, managers reconstruct a year in a few weeks.

  • Feedback arrives late. Issues that weren't raised during the year show up for the first time in a formal evaluation. One HR leader we spoke with wanted to end exactly that: employees getting unexpected feedback in their review.

  • Completion becomes the goal. With large teams and tight deadlines, scores and sign-offs crowd out coaching and development.

  • Rigid workflows add steps. Sequential approvals and manual workarounds make every review take longer than it should.

A review that looks backward, gets written from memory, and arrives in a rush can't tell a manager what to prioritize next quarter. It can't help leaders decide faster, either. It documents the past. Hospitals need it to help run the present.

Here's what the data does and doesn't show. Our survey measures perception, and it can't establish that manager workload causes the gap. Other factors are likely at work. Goals that don't reflect what employees can actually influence are one (more on that in a later post). But the pieces fit together: the size of the gap, independent data on nurse leader workload, and what hospital leaders describe when they talk about their review cycles.

If you're deciding where to start, start with the managers. For more on why strategy stalls at that layer, read The Manager Layer Is Breaking Your Performance Strategy — And AI Is the Fix.


The answer isn't another process for managers to run

Performance management is how strategy reaches the floor, and in a hospital, it runs through managers. Protecting their time is a business decision, not a courtesy.

Telling managers to review better won't fix a capacity problem. Changing how much work a review takes will. Four principles:

  1. Spread the work across the year. Capture goals, feedback, and accomplishments as they happen, so the review draws on a running record instead of a year of memory. It also eases the October-to-December crunch that some health systems face.

  2. Let the record write the first draft. Summaries built from documented goals, feedback, and conversation history cut preparation time. Managers still make the call. They just don't start from a blank page.

  3. Fit the review to the team. A nurse manager overseeing dozens of people needs a different cadence than a senior leader with a small team. Optional steps and flexible cycles keep every group from being forced through the same sequence.

  4. Keep the documentation hospitals need. A lighter process still needs a defensible record. Leaders we've spoken with raised the need to keep evidence behind assessments for accreditation reviews, and nursing peer-review requirements tied to Magnet recognition. A record that builds all year makes that easier, not harder.

Two timelines contrast reconstructing performance at year-end with capturing goals, feedback, and accomplishments throughout the year to support review drafts and manager conversations.

The test for any change is simple. Does it take work off a manager's plate, or does it just move it somewhere else? For more on taking friction out of managers' jobs, read Managers don't need more expectations. They need less friction.


How Betterworks takes work off the healthcare manager's plate

Betterworks brings goals, feedback, and conversations together so the record builds throughout the year and reviews draw on it:

  • Conversations: Scheduled and anytime reviews, configurable templates, optional steps, and asynchronous workflows let managers complete evaluations without a rigid, step-by-step sequence

  • Feedback: Give, request, and recognize contributions all year, so there's an ongoing record to draw from at review time

  • Goals: AI-assisted goal creation and simple progress updates help keep goals current without manual chasing

  • AI performance summaries: Documented goals, feedback, and conversation history come together in a summary, with writing assistance to help managers draft more informed evaluations. Managers stay in control of the final call

  • Integrations: Where your organization supports them, Microsoft Teams, Outlook, and Slack let people complete performance activities in tools they already use

Betterworks works alongside existing HCM systems, including Workday and SAP SuccessFactors, so hospitals can improve the review experience without replacing their system of record. Our Professional Services team, grounded in organizational psychology, helps design a program that fits your teams and supports adoption.

See how managers draft evaluations from documented goals and feedback instead of memory.

Book a Demo


Five questions to ask before your next review cycle

Before you change anything, find out where the work is piling up:

  1. How many people report to your largest-span managers, and when are their evaluations due? Look for clusters in your highest-demand months.

  2. How much of each review is written from memory? If there's no running record, the answer is probably "most of it."

  3. Where does feedback live between cycles? Spreadsheets, calendar reminders, and good intentions all count as answers.

  4. Do employees hear anything for the first time in their review? That's a sign coaching isn't happening when it's needed.

  5. Would your business leaders say reviews help managers prioritize? Only 55% of healthcare business leaders in our research said yes. Ask yours.

If your answers are "a lot," "months," and "I'm not sure," the problem probably isn't your managers' effort.

Not sure where your review process is breaking down? Let's talk through it.

Talk to an Expert

Related articles

Go deeper on Manager Enablement